- One persistent weakness in public development programmes is the tendency to equate completed construction with successful transformation. A dock is built, a cold storage facility is inaugurated, an ice plant is installed, and the project is reported as an achievement.
- These outputs are visible, measurable, and politically attractive. Yet the existence of infrastructure tells us very little about whether it is being used effectively or whether it has improved the livelihoods of its intended beneficiaries.
- The central issue, therefore, is not whether infrastructure should be built. Coastal communities urgently need appropriate infrastructure. The issue is whether public investment is accompanied by the institutional capacity, financing arrangements, business management, and community participation required to make those assets productive.
By Baharuddin Solongi, Researcher, University of Andi Djemma, Palopo
MARITIMEPOSTS.COM – The most important question about Indonesia’s coastal development is not how many fishing villages have received new infrastructure, but whether the people who depend on the sea are becoming more secure, prosperous, and independent.
A modern fishing dock may transform the appearance of a coastal settlement, but it cannot, by itself, transform the economic realities of the families who live there. Behind every newly constructed facility is a more difficult question: does it improve the lives of fishermen, or does it simply add another public asset whose benefits remain uncertain?
This distinction matters enormously in Luwu Raya, South Sulawesi, where the sea is both a source of livelihood and a daily encounter with economic uncertainty. Before sunrise, small-scale fishermen prepare their boats, calculate fuel expenses, check their equipment, and head offshore without knowing whether the day’s catch will cover their operational costs.
Their risks do not end when they return to land. Fish must be sold quickly, prices fluctuate, preservation facilities are often inadequate, and access to markets can be controlled by intermediaries. Even a productive fishing trip does not necessarily translate into a meaningful improvement in household welfare.
This is the coastal paradox of Indonesia: a country endowed with extraordinary marine resources, yet many of the people who produce its fisheries wealth continue to experience economic insecurity.
The Ministry of Marine Affairs and Fisheries (KKP), citing Central Statistics Agency (BPS) data in its 2025–2029 Strategic Plan, reports that 17.1 percent of Indonesian fishermen were living below the poverty line in 2023. Meanwhile, the number of marine capture fishermen increased from approximately 2.09 million in 2019 to 2.82 million in 2024, according to the figures presented in the policy material. These numbers point to a fundamental development challenge.
Expanding the population engaged in fishing does not automatically expand economic opportunity or social protection.
The government’s Kampung Nelayan Merah Putih (KNMP) initiative therefore arrives at a critical moment.
It offers an opportunity to strengthen coastal infrastructure, improve fisheries services, and create more integrated economic activities in fishing settlements. But its long-term significance will depend on whether the programme moves beyond physical construction and addresses the institutional, economic, and social conditions that reproduce coastal poverty.
Infrastructure is necessary, but it is not development itself
One persistent weakness in public development programmes is the tendency to equate completed construction with successful transformation. A dock is built, a cold storage facility is inaugurated, an ice plant is installed, and the project is reported as an achievement.
These outputs are visible, measurable, and politically attractive. Yet the existence of infrastructure tells us very little about whether it is being used effectively or whether it has improved the livelihoods of its intended beneficiaries.
A cold storage facility, for example, is only economically useful when electricity is reliable, operating costs are affordable, management is competent, and fishermen can access its services under transparent conditions.
An ice plant will not necessarily improve fishermen’s bargaining positions if distribution remains expensive or controlled by a limited number of suppliers. A landing facility may become an impressive physical asset while the people who use it continue to sell their catch at prices they cannot negotiate.
The central issue, therefore, is not whether infrastructure should be built. Coastal communities urgently need appropriate infrastructure. The issue is whether public investment is accompanied by the institutional capacity, financing arrangements, business management, and community participation required to make those assets productive.
This argument is consistent with Amartya Sen’s Capability Approach, which understands development as the expansion of people’s substantive freedoms and their ability to pursue lives they have reason to value. From this perspective, a fishing facility is a means, not an end. Its value should be assessed by the capabilities it creates: better access to markets, greater control over economic decisions, improved household security, and stronger opportunities for the next generation.
Development should not stop at constructing facilities. It must expand what people are actually able to do with them.
Coastal poverty is a structural problem
It is equally misleading to explain fishermen’s poverty primarily through individual effort, limited skills, or a lack of entrepreneurial ambition. Such explanations overlook the structural conditions that shape their economic choices.
Consider a fisherman who must borrow money to repair an engine, purchase fuel, and prepare for a fishing trip. If he has no affordable source of working capital, he may become dependent on a buyer or intermediary who provides financial assistance in exchange for an agreement to sell the catch at a predetermined price. The arrangement may provide immediate liquidity, but it can also weaken the fisherman’s ability to negotiate. When the catch is poor, debt accumulates. When the price falls, the fisherman has little room to refuse the transaction.
This is not simply a problem of individual financial management. It reflects an unequal economic relationship in which producers carry substantial operational risks but have limited control over financing, distribution, and final prices.
Social protection reveals another dimension of this vulnerability. The policy figures cited in the material indicate that only around a quarter of active fishermen are covered by specialized fisheries insurance, while approximately 71 percent of marine fishermen are not registered with BPJS Ketenagakerjaan. These figures require attention not merely as administrative statistics, but as indicators of exposure to risk. Fishing is an occupation involving accidents, unpredictable weather, equipment failure, and interruptions to income. Without adequate protection, one accident or prolonged period of bad weather can push an entire household into deeper poverty.
The state must therefore recognize fishermen not simply as beneficiaries of infrastructure programmes, but as workers and economic actors entitled to protection, fair market access, and opportunities to improve their livelihoods.
Empowerment requires an integrated economic ecosystem
If KNMP is to become an instrument of lasting change, its implementation needs to connect five dimensions that are too often handled separately.
First, development must begin with participatory socio-economic mapping. Fishing communities are not homogeneous. Their fleets, target species, seasonal patterns, market relationships, household income structures, and access to services differ considerably. Women who process and sell seafood, crew members who do not own vessels, small traders, and young people in coastal settlements also have economic roles that must be recognized. Without an accurate understanding of these differences, standardised interventions may benefit those who already possess assets while leaving the most vulnerable groups behind.
Second, fishermen’s cooperatives need to become genuine economic institutions. Cooperatives should not exist merely to satisfy administrative requirements or distribute assistance. They must have the managerial capacity to consolidate catches, procure production inputs, manage shared facilities, maintain transparent financial records, and negotiate better market arrangements. This requires professional management, accountable leadership, and continuous institutional support.
Third, coastal development must strengthen the entire fisheries value chain. Fishermen should not remain confined to selling unprocessed fish at the landing site. Opportunities for processing, packaging, quality certification, cold-chain distribution, and direct market partnerships can help retain more economic value within coastal communities. Connections with seafood processors, hotels, restaurants, modern retailers, and regional trading networks should be developed according to local production capacity and market demand.
Fourth, universities and research institutions should become active partners in the transformation process. Universitas Andi Djemma in Palopo, for example, has an opportunity to contribute through applied research, appropriate technology, business incubation, institutional assistance, and the development of locally relevant economic models. Research must not remain confined to academic publications. Its practical value should be measured by whether it helps communities solve real problems, improve productivity, and make better economic decisions.
Fifth, economic empowerment must be integrated with social protection and environmental sustainability. Insurance, occupational safety, access to subsidized fuel, financial services, and legal protection must accompany improvements in production and marketing. At the same time, mangrove ecosystems, coastal habitats, and sustainable fishing practices must be protected. Economic progress that depletes the natural resources on which fishing communities depend will only transfer poverty from one generation to another.
These priorities are consistent with the broader responsibilities established under Law No. 7 of 2016 concerning the Protection and Empowerment of Fishermen, Fish Farmers, and Salt Farmers. The law provides a basis for government intervention in protection, capacity building, and empowerment, including attention to women and other actors in coastal economic activities. Its significance lies in reminding policymakers that development is not simply the delivery of physical facilities, but also the fulfilment of public responsibilities toward vulnerable economic groups.
From measuring construction to measuring human progress
The most consequential change required in coastal policy is a change in how government defines success.
Traditional project evaluation often concentrates on outputs: budget absorption, construction completion, the number of facilities delivered, and the percentage of physical progress. These indicators are important for administrative accountability, but they cannot establish whether a programme has transformed people’s lives.
KNMP needs a stronger outcome-based evaluation framework. Are fishermen’s household incomes increasing? Have their production costs become more manageable? Are they receiving better prices for their catch? Has access to insurance and employment protection improved? Are women gaining greater participation in local economic decision-making? Are fishing families able to finance their children’s education? Are marine resources being managed sustainably?
These questions bring public investment closer to the realities it is supposed to change.
They also demand a more accountable relationship between central government, local governments, cooperatives, universities, private businesses, and fishing communities. No single institution can resolve the complexity of coastal poverty. Infrastructure providers cannot substitute for market institutions; local governments cannot rely entirely on central funding; and community participation cannot be meaningful without access to information and decision-making authority.
The challenge is to build an ecosystem in which each actor has a clear responsibility and the people who depend on the sea have a meaningful voice.
The dignity behind every fishing village
KNMP represents an important opportunity to rethink the future of Indonesia’s coastal economy. But its success will not be determined by the visual transformation of fishing settlements alone. A village may have a new dock, modern storage facilities, and improved public spaces, yet its fishermen may remain trapped in debt, exposed to occupational risks, and unable to secure fair prices for their catch.
That would be a contradiction between the appearance of development and its actual substance.
The real measure of success is not how impressive a dock looks, how large a cold storage facility becomes, or how many buildings are inaugurated. It is whether fishermen earn better incomes, their families enjoy greater security, their children have wider opportunities, and marine resources remain productive for future generations.
This is why coastal development must be understood as a question of human dignity. Fishermen should not be treated merely as recipients of government assistance or as instruments for achieving national production targets. They are workers, producers, citizens, and custodians of an important part of Indonesia’s maritime heritage.
Building a fishing village is an act of construction. Building the capacity, security, and dignity of its people is an act of civilization.
Indonesia must decide what it ultimately wants its coastal development programmes to leave behind. The answer should not be measured only in concrete, steel, and completed facilities, but in the lives made more secure, the economic opportunities made more equal, and the dignity restored to the people who go to sea every day.
___
Baharuddin Solongi is a researcher and academic at Universitas Andi Djemma (Unanda), Palopo, South Sulawesi.
Editorial note: This essay develops the policy arguments and figures supplied in the source material. The statistical references, programme targets, and regulatory provisions should be checked against the latest official KKP, BPS, and legal documents before publication. In particular, the cited KNMP implementation figures are time-specific and should be accompanied by their reporting dates.











